Outreach: It’s Your Responsibility, But Not Your Identity

Welcome back to the 40th issue of Disrupting Conversations!

Have you ever noticed how much power rejection holds over us? In sales, it can often be the #1 reason why someone doesn’t succeed. You can have all the technical expertise in the world, but what happens when you can’t consistently get in front of potential prospects/buyers? This is the wall that most can’t get over— it's the negative and compounding emotional weight of outreach.

When a prospect doesn't return your call or dismisses your email with a curt response, it's easy to feel personally wounded. But what if I told you that this feeling stems from a fundamental mistake we all make: internalizing our experiences and results in a landscape over which we have no control. We confuse our role with our identity. 

Today, let's explore why this identity trap exists, how it sabotages your performance, and what you can do to break free from it.

– Dan

Breaking Sales is my podcast to connect with those who are ready to break free from the chains of old sales methodologies that don’t work.

Title of Episode: What Are You Really Running From?

🎙️ One of the hardest things in sales is putting yourself out there, risking rejection day after day. But what if the real challenge isn't the rejection itself, but how we perceive it? In this episode, Pam and I explore why we avoid uncomfortable moments—like prospecting or difficult conversations—and how these avoidance patterns often stem from confusing our professional role with our personal identity.

We break down what's really happening in your brain when you label prospecting as "hard" rather than simply "uncomfortable," and why this distinction matters tremendously. When you understand that rejection of your outreach isn't rejection of you as a person, those uncomfortable moments become more manageable.

This shift in mindset is what enables you to embrace the uncomfortable moments that ultimately lead to growth and success.

Outreach: It’s Your Responsibility, But Not Your Identity

Picture this scenario: You've blocked off three hours for prospecting. You've researched your targets, crafted thoughtful messages, and mentally prepared to reach out. Then, as you sit down to begin, a wave of anxiety washes over you.

What if no one responds? 

What if they tell me to get lost? 

You know, that client deliverable still needs to be completed—let’s get that done first. 

Before you know it, your prospecting time has vanished, and the weight of avoidance follows you into tomorrow, growing heavier with each passing day.

If this sounds familiar, you're experiencing what I call the "identity trap"—and it's one of the biggest obstacles to sales success.

Role vs. Identity: A Critical Distinction

Let's get something straight: When you're paid to perform the role of a sales professional, your responsibilities include opening doors, uncovering prospects, and bringing in new business. That's your role—but it isn't who you are.

Your identity as a human being runs deeper than any professional function. It encompasses your values, relationships, character, and countless other dimensions that exist completely separate from your sales performance.

👉 Yet, when a prospect rejects your outreach, what happens? Most of us instinctively interpret this as personal rejection. We think: "They rejected me" rather than "They weren't interested in discussing this particular topic at this moment."

This confusion between role and identity creates a negative framework around prospecting. Each non-response or rejection feels like a judgment on our worth rather than a simple business decision made by someone who likely doesn't know us at all.

Breaking Free from the Identity Trap

The most effective sales professionals I've coached have mastered the ability to maintain this crucial separation. Here's how you can practice it:

1. Mindset preparation: Before any prospecting session, take a moment to remind yourself: "I am performing a role for which I'm compensated. Any rejection is of the topic or timing, not of me as a person."

2. Focus on what you can control: You'll never control how or if someone responds to your outreach. Instead of fixating on outcomes, focus on consistent action and quality of effort.

3. Acknowledge the weight: When you avoid prospecting, that weight doesn't disappear—it compounds. Recognize that doing the work, even imperfectly, feels better than carrying the burden of avoidance.

4. Create mental distance: When rejection occurs, practice observing it objectively. "That prospect wasn't interested in my offering" rather than "I failed" or "I'm not good enough."

This distinction might seem subtle, but its impact is profound. When you separate your role from your identity, prospecting becomes a series of professional interactions rather than personal judgments. You can perform consistently without the emotional rollercoaster that comes from tying your self-worth to outcomes you can't control.

Remember: Your value doesn't decrease based on someone's inability to see your worth—especially when that "someone" is merely declining a business conversation about a topic they may not currently prioritize.

The next time you sit down to prospect, try this approach. You might be surprised how much lighter and more effective you feel when you're no longer placing your identity on the line with every outreach.

Thanks for reading!

Want to know more about the work I’m doing? Follow me on LinkedIn.

Was this newsletter shared with you? Subscribe here.

Learn more about Lappin180.