What’s Your Brain Doing When the Stakes Are High?

Welcome back to the 58th issue of Disrupting Conversations!

If you ask a room full of 500 sales professionals to raise their hands if they consider themselves self-aware, 498 hands will go up. 

Research tells a different story. 

By some measurements, only 10–15% of people are actually self-aware. This means that the vast majority of people are operating with a blind spot they don’t even know they have… and it’s costing them more than they think. 

Why? Because self-awareness isn’t just another “soft skill.” It’s the ability to hear what you’re actually saying to yourself in the moments that count, and to decide whether that story is serving you or sabotaging you. That’s the foundation of every high-stakes conversation you’ll ever have: with your boss, your prospects, your family, you name it. 

Without self-awareness, the voice in your head is running the show before you even say a word. And the first step to taking back control is understanding what’s really driving your thinking when the pressure is on.

– Dan

Breaking Sales is my podcast to connect with those who are ready to break free from the chains of old sales methodologies that don’t work.

Title of Episode: High Performance Self-Talk with Psychologist Rachel Turow

🎙️ Before you can effectively change what you say in a high-stakes conversation, you have to understand what’s happening inside your own head. In this episode, I sit down with psychologist and researcher Rachel Turow to dig into the science of self-talk. We explore how the vast majority of our thinking is routine and negative, how our internal narratives affect everything from our sales performance to our relationships, and what it actually takes to change the pattern.

When you walk into a high-stakes conversation, especially one where friction is likely, what’s going through your mind? You’re probably thinking things like: Be careful. Don’t screw this up. Are you sure you’re prepared for this?

That voice in your head is your brain doing exactly what it was designed to do. 

Human beings are neurologically wired to focus on the negative. Research shows that you can have a single negative experience with someone, and it will completely overshadow ten positive ones. We anchor ourselves to bad moments and do everything we can to avoid them. It’s a survival mechanism, one that’s kept us safe for thousands of years. 

So when you enter a tense conversation, your brain is already running a narrative designed to protect you from a negative response. In sales, this usually shows up in one of two ways. The first is the fear of rejection: You’ve identified a question you want to ask, but it’s going to require the prospect to invest some effort and honesty within their answer and that’s when the internal bargaining starts — What if it lands wrong? What if they pull back? — and the question never gets asked. 

The second is the need for validation: I need them to know I’m credible. I need them to know I’ve done this before. Instead of listening, you start performing, selling yourself instead of serving the prospect. The focus moves from understanding their situation to managing the prospect’s perception of you — and they feel it before you do.

Both of these narratives prioritize your comfort over the prospect’s actual need. 

Self-awareness is what gives you the ability to catch this self-talk in the moment. To recognize when the story you’re telling yourself is serving you, rather than the other person, and replace it with a better narrative. 

Here’s what that looks like in practice. I had a client who recently found himself at a crossroads after learning that part of a prospect’s business was awarded to a competitor. The decision had already been made, but the prospect was willing to leave the door open on the rest of the business.

The voice that showed up first sounded reasonable: This is still a win. Take the business they’re offering, and you can preserve the relationship without rocking the boat. 

Hard to argue with, right? Except splitting operations the way the prospect was proposing would create real inefficiencies in the business. The math didn’t work in the prospect’s favor, and my client knew it. 

My client recognized that first voice for what it was — self-protection disguised as pragmatism — and deliberately chose to reframe the narrative: If I just take half this deal, I’m doing them a disservice. I owe them an honest perspective, even if it means I don’t get the business.

Ultimately, he said what needed to be said: the split didn’t serve the prospect, and the better option was to consolidate — with my client’s firm or with the competitor’s, but not both. That was the harder conversation to have… but it was also the one the prospect needed to hear the most. 

This is what self-awareness looks like in action. And what it buys you isn’t confidence or certainty, but the clarity to recognize what your instincts are pushing you toward — and the discipline to take the better path.

QUOTE

“He who knows others is wise. He who knows himself is enlightened.” 

— Lao Tzu

Thanks for reading!

Want to know more about the work I’m doing? Follow me on LinkedIn.

Was this newsletter shared with you? Subscribe here.

Learn more about Lappin180.